Mary Oliver Knows What’s What

The neighborhood is quiet again. For six weeks during the summer, there’s a camp across the street. The kids are quite … audible from about 9AM to 4PM. It’s delightful, really, the sounds they make, their shrieks of laughter and chatter. Now, it’s easier, again, to hear birds but the noises of childhood are all gone. Probably that’s not true in most neighborhoods but ours is an older population. There are few children here and their giggles are muted. 

In her poem “Don’t Hesitate,” Mary Oliver writes, “Joy is not made to be a crumb.” She tells us to embrace the joyful moments we come upon because they are few and unexpected. Isn’t that a child’s laugh? The smell of the bread my daughter is baking? When my son teases me and we chuckle because I called Deadpool Spiderman? I can’t wait for an end to cancer to experience joy because there might not be an end to cancer but if we don’t seek it out and celebrate those found moments, there will definitely be an end to joy. 

It’s cycle 8, the last cycle of chemo for now. And it’s been full of delights – vomiting, attacks of unproductive nausea (if you know, you know), cold sweats, dizziness, and lots of unspecified gastrointestinal delights. At least I know I’ll have a break soon. 

My nails have started peeling but thankfully, my hands and feet are not. Yes, that’s a pretty common chemo thing – peeling appendages. Ken struggled with it. His feet especially looked like dried alligator skin. Nothing seemed to help him. I’ve been more fortunate and more responsive to my daughter’s entreaties to please use the body lotion people have so kindly sent me. It’s working; so, thanks, everyone. 

It gets tiresome, you know, to constantly think about your own wellbeing. We’re all mostly oblivious to the functions of our bodies until those parts are not quite working. Back aches, stomach upsets, sore feet are all experiences we’ve had and moved on from, not giving them a thought. But in the midst of an extended health event, everything is about what’s working and not. And after a bit, it’s annoying to be constantly spotting problems. 

One morning, I woke up thinking “I feel sick.” Then, I sat up and had terrible vertigo that did not end when I lay back down. Closing your eyes works (in case you ever experience vertigo). After a few moments, the dizziness was gone but the nausea stayed. I have to eat to take my chemo pills so I had a glass of milk for breakfast and an egg for dinner and nothing in between. Tiresome, you see what I mean? Who wants to constantly be thinking about whether they feel okay? 

Recently, I was shopping at Costco with my daughter – we had run out of milk which is a catastrophe in our house. We were discussing the merits of a clearance storage item when I suddenly felt very wonky and started to cold-sweat. My worst nightmare is to have a health event at Costco and there we were, health-event underway. I sat on one of their display sofas for a bit, visited the bathroom for reasons you can imagine without further explanation, sat on the sofa again, and then decided to wait in the car where I could direct air conditioning on my very sweaty brow. 

Alas, that was not to be as the car had a very dead battery. Yes, that’s right. A 90 degree day and a dead battery – so, back I went into Costco to sit on that convenient sofa. 

My daughter made sure I was okay on the sofa, did all the food selecting, checked out, and loaded the car. I took on the easier task of jumping the battery with our lovely battery charger (having one in the car is so unnecessary until your battery is dead!), with her providing the essential moral support because I was really going through something as we like to call it. On the way home, she even put up with the frigid car temperature so I could cool my very sweaty self. And then she put all the groceries away while I lay on the sofa. One of the silver linings, I guess, is having the opportunity to see my loved ones shine in my rather dark place. 

Next week starts my long chemo break. I’ll have scans in September and visits with my surgeon and oncologist in October. I wonder what our next steps will be.

Much love.

Mary Oliver Knows What’s What

Naps Are the New Normal

When I’m not feeling well, as has been the case for several days, I think about how well I would be feeling if I weren’t on chemo and how, despite feeling completely normal, I would be moving ever closer to death as the tumor inside me grew. That I am now cancer-free and feeling ill is the contrasting benefit to my wistful thoughts of wellness, the longing for the pleasure of spring planting and days working beside a big, open coffee shop door.

One of the strategies the oncology therapist has been trying to drill into my head is – conserve energy. Use a terry cloth robe instead of drying off after a shower. Sit to chop the veg for dinner. Take naps. Exercise in brief sessions throughout the day – three 10-minute walks instead of a 30-minute one. It’s hard to acknowledge that some things have to change. I’m not sick but damn this chemo is kicking my butt. 

Today, it’s warm but my toes are suffering from chemo-cold. My fluffy blue socks were a gift from a friend who beat breast cancer. It’s a common theme – apparently – the cold chemo feet. The socks are great and include a non-slip message to cancer: something about me being a bad bitch. I highly recommend them. They’re very snuggly. I also hate them because they too are a marker that all is not as it should be. Instead of socks, I should be padding barefoot through the house and out the back door to sit on the deck. Whine, whine, whine. I am grateful. I AM. But feeling unwell messes with my already chemo-fogged brain, making rational thought an occasional visitor rather than the constant companion I prefer.

My chemo break week has been something of a chemo-tastrophe. I got another infection. My blood work shows that my body is still fighting it. On top of that, I’ve been so drowsy and irritable that I haven’t been able to stand myself. I honestly don’t know how my kids are putting up with me. It’s so bad that I’m almost looking forward to going back on the chemo on Monday. Almost. 

I was warned by those who came before that chemo break is terrible for everyone, which makes it no break at all, you know? I do feel somewhat better today, of course, because it’s the day before chemo starts again. 

We’re getting a new roof, something I put off longer than I should have. I’ve been meeting with contractors about the work and it’s been a right pain in the patootie. One of them tried to bully me. Another gave me a quote of $40,000. Seriously. I mean, my roof is going to be expensive but really? One of the roofers told me to talk to my husband about the quote. 

Back to the point, one of the contractors insisted on socializing with me, a bonding effort perhaps, and I finally said, “hey, I apologize but I’m on chemo and it’s kicking my ass. I’m going to sit during this.” How does he respond? By telling me about all the people he knows who have died of cancer. What? Don’t tell me that people die from cancer. This is something I already know. It’s like when I was pregnant and people told me all of their delivery horror stories. Let’s not, my friends. I already know that cancer is a killer. That’s literally why I’m on chemo. 

Earlier in the week, I was re-watching the Barbie movie with my daughter and I kept thinking that I was too tired to do any of the things they were doing. Jump out of bed and make breakfast? Nope. Go to the beach? Only if I can lie down. Escape to the real world? Maybe if they put in more benches so I can sit. 

Even with all this, I’ve been walking as much as I can. It’s a challenge to hit the step goals I set for myself but I’m trying. Last night when I went up to bed, I accidentally left my water bottle on the first floor and then had a little mental discussion (argument? pep talk?) about whether I actually needed to drink water during the night. The answer is yes. Chemo dehydration is dangerous. It causes fainting and dizziness and other bad stuff. So, I walked the two flights to the first floor and back up to bed. Hit my step goal too. 

Much love. And naps.

Naps Are the New Normal

Take Time to Smell … Paint Stripper?

The nightmare was bad, the kind that makes you choose not to sleep for the remainder of the night. It was 4ish when I awoke, though, so I lay in bed, listening to the sounds of the early morning: two foxes talking as they headed toward the park, early birds calling to each other – more likely warning others off but as a non-speaker of bird, I couldn’t say for sure. 

There was a gentle movement at my back. One of my doxies has been sleeping with me; and curled tightly against my back in my cold bedroom, she was dreaming, her paws twitching, her tail occasionally wagging. She wouldn’t want me to tell you this part … her small, pink tongue was sticking out of her mouth just slightly.

My oncology check-in was uneventful. The care team is mostly happy with my situation, reminding me to drink at least 64 ounces of water every day and moisturize, moisturize, moisturize. They Snow White-d me when I arrived:  “Let me see your hands.” It made me laugh but I doubt they got the reference, especially not the PA who seems somewhat humorless.

I’m doing well, more tired than I think I’m capable of describing. And wow, the chemo brain has set in. I forget the most mundane things – things I’ve never before forgotten. You can advise me to make lists and use a calendar – go ahead; I know you want to. Funny thing is, I do both and I STILL forget really mundane things. We’re talking about everything from a take-out order for one of my kids to a grocery item to a doctor appointment. 

Haley and I walked 10,800+ steps yesterday. It was cold and windy, not the best time to marathon-walk. Nonetheless, we walked. At day’s end, I was so tired that I tried to go to bed without eating, not feeling in the least inclined to bother. But all three of the kids stepped in to make sure I ate: Wheat Chex (the best Chex cereal; I will accept no argument to the contrary) and a banana was my choice and it was about all I could manage, lol. 

Today, we’re back at the spring cleaning. It’s been so much fun. I can see why the Maria Kondo’s of the world encourage it, though I think you have to be in the right mindset to see the value. We’re excited to be freeing ourselves of the burden to care for objects that no longer serve; but even five years ago, we wouldn’t have been able to do this.

My favorite place – one that has helped us a lot through this experience – is Construction Junction, a re-use store here in Pittsburgh. I’ve donated the unwanted and found new treasures that I’m really excited about. For example, we got two antique light fixtures. One will replace the gaping hole in the ceiling where the previous light was before the screws in the – oops, they cut the hole too big – drywall gave way, allowing the fixture to fall off the ceiling and swing by fragile wires. Now, all I have to do is repair the drywall and paint before I can hang that light – next week, if the chemo doesn’t chop me off at my knees. 

We were planning to put the second fixture – yes, we have a place for that, actually two. Cleaning out is not successful if you add back in all sorts of new stuff. SMH Anyway, the final location for the second fixture was being hotly debated – over the dining room table or in the kitchen. The kitchen will win because we realized that the dining room ceiling – my turn for an oopsie – isn’t wired for a light. The current monstrosity has a cord and plug, which I KNEW, obviously, but just kind of forgot in the midst of my passionate argument in favor of the dining room. 

We are, however, considering solutions for the dining room. Both of us are leaning toward removing the monstrosity (donating to Construction Junction, of course) and using ambient light instead. The monstrosity is so big that it’s forehead level if we move the table AND it is impossible to clean. There are reasons to keep something that’s been labeled hard-to-clean but “hating it” isn’t one of them.

Work was interrupted multiple times by dogs. It was so nice that the puppies were convinced that it would be warm. They insisted, multiple times, that it would be warm THIS TIME. Their disappointment was palpable. Mine would be too if only I had fingerprints but they were stolen by capecitabine. I hope I get them back later this year because dropping stuff is freaking annoying. Still, we were able to enjoy the sun, if not the temperature. Soon, we’ll have both.

Much love and time to smell the spring flowers.  

Take Time to Smell … Paint Stripper?

Live(r) Your Life

I’ve spent so much time in hospitals that I have that instant clarity of meeting an old acquaintance and falling into conversation as though you’ve never been apart. No matter which hospital you are in, the smell, the sounds, the directions (follow the arrows for elevator E, bring your ticket for validation, show your ID to enter the building) are basically universal. 

And yet, despite that deep familiarity, there are things I always forget – the way patients wait for hours, the texture of the food, the unique kindnesses of the support staff, the emotions that fill the air, leaking from various open patient doorways – grief, panic, fear, acceptance, relief. 

Roomie 1, the OG, had already been in the hospital for a week when I arrived. She was angry, her mood emanating from her like a toxic gas. I celebrated her return home for her benefit and mine. #2 roomie was very elderly, stuffed into my room for the night for observation. She’d fallen out of a car and was pretty banged up. Roomie 2 was beloved by her family. She had so many phone calls and visitors that I wanted to remind them that she was supposed to be resting – and so was I. But she wasn’t even there 24 hours so I left my bitchy comments on my side of the floor.

My third roommate, let’s call her Marietta because that couldn’t be farther from her real name, arrived from another high monitor unit in the hospital. She was very sick. The hour was late. Her care team was with her into the early hours of the next morning. There’s no privacy in hospitals so, since I couldn’t sleep, I listened to the conversations. The staff talked to her, asked her questions. She frequently didn’t know what was going on, wasn’t aware of some of the care decisions that had been made. 

At some point, I was able to put together enough pieces to realize that she’d been unconscious, unable to consent to some of the care she received. We were in a high-monitor surgical oncology unit so it’s not that surprising. Things come up during surgery. My care team and I went through the major decision forks that could appear so that they would know what I wanted before the anesthesia was administered but that isn’t always an option. 

Eventually, her care team left for a few hours but the doctors round early. They arrived to talk with her before the sun was above the horizon. The discussion was one I’ve experienced. Hospital familiarity can be reassuring – sounds and codes don’t make me anxious but there’s a certain food served in the cafeteria that I can’t smell without feeling a cold sweat on my forehead. 

Anyway, she asked when she’d be shut of all the bags she was wearing. If you don’t know anything about these, just google ‘ostomy bag’ and you’ll have a general picture. Since Ken had colon cancer, I know quite a bit about ostomy bags because he was supposed to get at least one. While I sat in my curtained-off alcove, the doctors explained that she was entering palliative care. 

Have you any idea what it feels like to be sitting on your uncomfortable hospital bed, no headphones, unable to easily move around because you have four brand new and very sore holes in your abdomen, and nowhere else to go anyway, listening to a young doctor tell the unseen woman beside you that she is dying and there is nothing they can do to stop it? He kept saying “let’s focus on making the time you have left as pleasant as possible.” I know he meant well. I do. I had forgotten, perhaps on purpose, that this is another part of being in hospitals. 

Ken’s care team would use phrasing like “keep him comfortable” and “most potential for extending his awareness.” I wanted to go through the curtain and ask her if she understood what they were saying, though I could hear her tears. I also wanted with an all-consuming passion to be ANYWHERE ELSE. There are no exits from a locked unit but if I’d been allowed to walk unaided, I might have become a human ISS, traveling the unit hallways for the foreseeable future. 

We weren’t friendly, exactly. It’s hard to become even acquainted with one person (me) constantly resisting the connections that the other (her) continues to offer. We talked a little bit, occasionally. Each time I struggled with a task, she’d make strange offers of assistance – and what exactly are you going to do to help me, occupant 2 of Room 899B? Your care team won’t allow you out of bed so quit asking me if I need help. 

Because I can’t help you. I can’t.

I took many walks with a walker or when I could manage it, just holding my IV octopus – I had five active lines. Basically I was constantly tangled in or tangling things, some of which hurt when you tug on them. There was a young man, later 20s probably, taking the same walks I did, though he had a single room and wasn’t guilt-walking the corridor to hide from his terminal roommate. Like I said, it’s a surgical oncology unit so unlikely he was there to get a bunion removed. His gait was better than mine. He’d been walking longer. We’d pass each other on the route. There was little maneuvering room so occasional clipped wheels were common but we never spoke. 

Eventually, I’d have to return to my room. There’s no place else to go – bed, sitting upright, or chair, also sitting very upright. Marietta would launch a possible conversation grenade at me and I’d answer briefly before muttering about a nap or a sponge bath. In the early morning hours of my last day, we were both propped up in our spaces as the hospital began to come awake. “Can I say something?” she asked through the thin barriers of our privacy curtains. 

“Sure,” I said, sure that she was going to comment on her life or my evasiveness.

“Your daughter ….” She paused a moment. “Well, she’s beautiful but that’s not even what I want to say.” I heard her fidgeting. “You’re lucky. She’s wonderful. And I can tell that she loves you very much.” 

God help me. I wanted to cry, was determined not to cry, didn’t cry. I am so very lucky. She’s right and I know it. My children are amazing. Mostly, I asked them to stay away from the unit. We spent so many months, painful, traumatic months in hospital rooms. They did not need to see me beside a woman who is the living embodiment of their dad’s illness and future death. 

I thanked her and was quiet again. There aren’t good words to tell a dying woman that my blessing isn’t her curse. There are almost no good words to say to someone who is dying. When I left later that day, I walked around the curtain to meet her. She’s older than I thought, looks vaguely like a well-known comedian. Her hair, short like mine, is a vibrant color, startlingly against the hospital bed. 

When I spoke, she said, “Oh, you’re the woman behind the curtain.” 

I nodded and held up two unopened water bottles I had left. “You want my extra water?” I asked her. 

She smiled at me, her eyes tearing up again. “Yes, thank you,” she said. “Go. Live a joyful life.” Marietta waved her arm above her head like she was cracking a stage coach whip before a team of horses. “Go now. Live.”

Much love. 

Live(r) Your Life

A little rain under the robotic knife

Life is so crazy some days. And then others, you’re sitting on the side of the road in Texas waiting for the police officer to issue you a warning for doing absolutely nothing.

My paternal grandmother, Myrtle the Turtle Traffic Light, as my sister and I use to call her before dissolving into the sorts of giggles produced only by very young children, was the kind of woman who would absolutely have been a rule-breaker, a flapper, a radical feminist. She was a little bit wild, an assertive leader, who received surprisingly naughty letters from her future husband. Those letters have changed me (what is once seen cannot ever be unseen) in ways that are probably not for the better. I think I’d have preferred to see her letters instead of his but apparently men of that era were less inclined to keep love letters tied in a bundle.

Many years ago, probably in the late 1970s, Grandma MtTTL took my sister and me to see a version of The Ink Spots perform at The Brown Derby, a long-ago restaurant in Erie. We were the only children in the audience and those elderly men were absolutely delighted to introduce us to the music that has influenced so many musicians who came after. 

The Ink Spots profoundly proclaimed in one of their songs “Into every life, rain must fall.” No one, in the history of forever, has been more right than they were in that song. 

There’s a thing – it’s not X, Y. or Z. It could be an anomalous A or a blah, blah, blah. It’s big and it’s on my liver. By the time most of you read this, I will be in robotic surgery, after which I’ll rest in some high-monitor unit of a hospital. I’ll be lighter by 20% of my liver and grumpy. Neither of these would be normal for me; nor were they on my bingo card for 2024. See the above paragraphs for pithy wisdom about predicting your future.

Why am I telling you mid-event? Why am I telling you at all? Why me? (Why not me?) There are no good answers to these or many other questions. I won’t have access to technology for a few days and then I’ll be using my initially limited energy to finish a project I’ve been working on. I will check in, though, to let you all know about life with less liver.

Don’t worry about me. I’m in good hands and in good spirits. And I’ll have a cool scar to add to my collection. Maybe, if it’s worth it, I’ll write a blog about the experience. 

Life is crazy some days. 

Much love. 

A little rain under the robotic knife

The Endless End

Mortality is that person you never think about until they start texting you to “hang out.” They aren’t a friend or even an acquaintance, however you choose to define that. You’ve seen them in passing, at a funeral or in the eyes of an elderly neighbor, but you don’t KNOW them. 

It’s awkward, really. Because you have friends in common, you don’t want to upset them by ignoring their “have a chat” messages; but you also would rather pull out your own teeth than associate with Mortality. They’re so, so  …. What is there to say? They make you uncomfortable. You can’t quite put your finger on the problem, on why you dread interacting with them. 

They are oddly omnipresent at certain times of your life, too, which is beyond frustrating. Just when you most want peace and brightness, look who’s calling. It’s Mortality with a “you up” message that’s as far from sexy as your partner saying, “who gets to use the bathroom first?”

It’s 3AM. You’ve kept your eyes closed for hours in a determined attempt to sleep even though there’s no chance it will work. All of a sudden, there’s an almost physical tap on your shoulder. Mortality has tucked themselves into bed next to you and they want to chat. You’re sure that, if you could just lie still for another minute, you’d fall asleep but not with Mortality in the bed. Worse than them wanting to talk is their preferred topic: all the things you least want to discuss. 

“Want to talk about things you regret, times you hurt someone whether intentionally or not, the all the things you might never get to do again?” Ouch. It’s as painful as a parental look back on all the ‘last times’ you did something with your child – the final time you: carried them up to their bed, gave them a piggy back ride, tucked them in, read them a story, played with them. Oh, hey, Mortality, thanks so much for bringing up all the other potential LASTS in our futures and our pasts. 

Mortality isn’t vindictive. Imagine if they were. The merciless brutality of their existence would be worsened incalculably if the focus of their attention was also their latest victim. The potential for true cruelty is endless. “Hey, Mortality here, let’s talk about that time you watched your crush kiss your best friend.” Instead, Mortality is just saying, in the gentlest manner, “hey, thinking about you” and “are you thinking about me?” 

God, yes, I am but I sure wish I weren’t. 

Much love.

The Endless End

A Thousand Ways to Ruin a Wreath

My eldest and I were joking today about wreath-making. It was the annual Nature’s Wreath fund-raiser at the Pittsburgh Zoo. We go every year and — every year — we agonize over our wreath decorating. I was (secretly) absolutely delighted … Okay. Okay. Flattered beyond the power of speech is more accurate … when our long-time wreath mentor told me that (after 25 years of making wreaths), I’m starting to show real growth. I can’t even tell you how much that made me laugh.

Anyway, I was encouraging my son not to over-think his wreath design, told him there’s no wrong way to design it. And that’s when he looked up from his work, his green eyes bright with laughter, and said, “Maybe not, Mom, but there are a thousand ways to ruin a wreath.”

It’s the single best thing, you know. The time you spend with people. Let me amend that — the time that you are physically, mentally, and emotionally present with people. For years, I was required to vacation with my phone at the ready, with my laptop in my tent. I had to check email. I was chided for not responding quickly enough. I attended meetings while my children road rides at Universal Studios. I sat at a table in Dave & Busters on a call with a project manager while my son ate nachos and waited for me to play with him. I was not present.

Today, there were no conference calls separating me from family and friends. We laughed and teased and shared suggestions. We pranked each other by sneaking unexpected items onto wreaths and sang along to silly holiday tunes. We praised other participants’ wreaths and made terrible hot cocoa with boiling water and packets of Swiss Miss. We started the day with cheap diner food at a sticky table and stayed an extra hour talking. It was one of those spectacular small moments in our lives that are so easily missed, that cannot be recaptured.

When one of my kids asked what I want for Christmas, I said, “More of this. More time together. The gift of your presence.” I think, perhaps, nothing else matters.

Much love.

A Thousand Ways to Ruin a Wreath

The Last Red Leaf

Okay, who shortened October and November? The last time I checked in, the leaves were beginning to flame and temperatures were dropping. Bad news: I was just outside. There’s one tree on the street yelling “I’m still gorgeous” with its bright red leaves while all of the surrounding plants have covered themselves in a shroud of gray silence to wait for spring.  

My pneumonia was confirmed – ground glass opacities in the lungs, in case you’re interested in the details. I’m better, still coughing but no longer struggling to inhale. When I go out, I make the occasional announcement – asthma, not covid – or wave my inhaler around if I happen to have a coughing spate. 

In fact, I’m feeling so healthy I had the opportunity to take my neighbor shopping. She wanted to go to Marshall’s but doesn’t like to drive on the highway. Since I’m soundly somewhere between her kids and grandkids age-wise, I have the pleasure of being her chauffeur. After shopping, she treated me to an iced tea and a bagel (and a little bag of biscotti to share). We sat for an hour and talked. I think she likes to go with me because I’m a new audience for her stories. She has led an amazing life and is an excellent storyteller so, honestly, I don’t mind.

Also, FINALLY, after eight weeks of coughing, I felt well enough to drive to Erie to see my not-my-aunt Ginny. She said that she thought I was mad at her since I haven’t been to see her in so long. She has cognitive decline, as I mentioned before, and thought my last visit had been before Christmas. I showed her our most recent selfie together. She didn’t remember, of course, but it made her feel better to know that I do usually visit regularly and that I wasn’t mad. (I don’t talk about illness because it just makes her fuss and worry.) 

The sad thing about her decline is that I can’t give her anything physical to comfort her because she loses the memory almost immediately after I leave. I visit her because I know it makes her happy in the moment and because someday it will be all I have left of her. And while that might sound melancholy, I really just mean it as a truth. All of us will one day exist only as a memory for someone else. 

Perhaps we should all work to make that memory a good one.

Much love.

The Last Red Leaf

To Have the Audacity of Barbie

The catbirds have gone silent. Every morning, lately, a young hawk begins calling as the sun peeks over the horizon. Hunting, I assume, though only the hunted and the hawks really know. She woke me again today, a few moments before my alarm reminded me not to burrow back into the pillow. The day is too full for extended sleep to be an option. And so, the day begins.

Walking in the early morning light the mile or two back from the mechanic where I left the car, I saw a man eating a boxed meal in the portico of an abandoned building. He’s made a home there, his bedding tucked under the roof, shopping car(t) parked next to his sidewalk-driveway. There’s no garbage pick-up, of course, but he’s keeping his very public little home tidy, his trash collected in plastic grocery bags and stacked neatly. He’s chosen an excellent location for his residence. The portico is barely visible from the street, essential for his safety, since the city regularly harasses those who are too public about their unhomed status. 

He’s living in one of the neighborhoods that needs healthy revitalization, not gentrification. I suspect, though, that the local government finds gentrification more financially beneficial. Until that changes, another community will lose its personality and culture to cookie-cutter high-rise apartments funded by greedy VCs and politicians. 

The neighborhood used to have a common grocery store, not a particularly safe one, unfortunately, but at least it was affordable. That store was torn down to make room for … another apartment building. Now, the primary grocery option is a Whole Foods, a store that reinforces the idea that food deserts are often, very specifically, places where the available food is not affordable. It’s remarkably effective – and completely lacking in human decency – if the goal is to remove financially fragile renters from a neighborhood. 

Three blocks beyond ‘portico house’, the neighborhood changes naturally as the landscape changes. That’s where I often spend the day. There are several local coffee shops, plus that national union-busting place (you know the one). Things have begun to change too at my favorite third place. I understand with horrible clarity how very irrelevant it is to desire the status quo. The world does not ask permission to change. People don’t either and isn’t that the worst betrayal? To expect everyone to stay where they are when, in reality, you will always, always be running to catch up. 

Children are an excellent example of that. But despite my years of experience being surprised by the various children in my world, I am still continually left stumbling along behind as they roar into their days with apparent fearless abandon. I am (probably not so) secretly constantly on the verge of a gasp with relief and admiration at their audacity.

Where did mine go? I’m absolutely certain that at one point in my life, my dear, so beloved mother was also gasping at my audaciousness. Now, instead of moving fearlessly to new cities where I have no connections, I find myself whining about the lack of black iced tea at my coffee shop. Nothing to fear – they steeped tea just for me since they’ve run out of the already-brewed stuff. And how embarrassingly privileged that is.

Over the weekend, I made a bunch of bracelets. One of my favorites from the Barbie movie is “Humans only have one ending.” There’s something reassuring about knowing that I only have this one life and that it’s on me to continually make a damned effort to do better. 

Another favorite, and the one on my wrist today, is a modification of the Barbie scene in which Barbie tells an elderly woman, “You’re beautiful.” And the woman responds, “I know.” 

And you are beautiful. I hope you know that.

Much love.

To Have the Audacity of Barbie

To My Mother

Mom’s high school grad picture

Happy Mother’s Day, Mom. 

You left us 26 years ago on a cold day in January. The 9th day to be specific. At the time, there were three grandbabies. You met all three though, I’m sorry if this hurts you, they never really knew you. 

Now there are six grandchildren – three boys and three girls. I talk and write about you but it’s not the same. Of course it isn’t. How could anything but your presence paint more than a rough portrait of you? 

I’ve told my daughter – almost 25 years old now – all about your sewing skills, your drawing ability, your fashion sense. She asks sometimes what you would think of something she made. Like the blankets she crocheted. I told her that my sister and I taught you to crochet when we learned in our Home Econ class in high school. 

Mom on her wedding day, 08/25/1956

You were always a quick study, learning new skills at will, though never giving yourself credit for the effort that takes. Instead, you beat yourself up your entire life for not going to college. I’m not even convinced that you wanted a college education, though you totally could have done it. I know that your mom wanted you to go to college, perhaps because that wasn’t an option for Grandma. 

My kids all know about your green thumb, Mom, about how you could get anything – except violets – to grow. Do you remember how I used to tease you because I could grow violets? I was so proud of being able to do something you couldn’t do. Having a special touch with violets made me feel 10 feet tall. Somehow, after leaving home, I completely lost my skill. I haven’t been able to keep a violet alive since I was 20 years old. Rather suspicious, don’t you think? 

You also taught me about secrets, though it may have been an unintended lesson. I’ve never met a better secret keeper than you. In truth, it’s unlikely I ever will. My children learned, instead, the danger of secrets. We are open books, thinking, perhaps, that talking is a better way of living. I don’t blame you. I doubt that there was any generation more emotionally unavailable than the children of two world wars (my grandparents). How could you possibly be open when your own parents were so stoic, so remarkably inaccessible?

I miss you every day, you know. When I pull out your cookbook or the recipes written in your elegant script, I think about what it was like to work in the kitchen with you. Your pies were the stuff of legend. No one who bought them from the many, many bake sales for school events and Girl Scouts ever knew how often you cried while you made the crust. No matter how much you fussed that you’d lost your touch, each crust was perfect, flaky and delicious. I’ve never – even using your recipe and your rolling pin – made a crust as good as yours. 

My eldest son has stood beside me – 5 inches taller with a full beard – to make pies just like you and I did. Strawberry, apple, rhubarb, key lime, lemon meringue – we’ve made them all. Do you remember how much you hated the graham cracker crust that we made for strawberry pie? You’d say, every time, that the graham cracker flavor was overbearing. And I say, every time I make one, that you never liked that graham cracker crust. What do you suppose my kids will say when they make strawberry pie in their own homes?

Sometimes, when I make a meal using a recipe that isn’t yours, I’ll look at your version just to remember, again, what it was like to sit in the kitchen doing homework while you and I talked. My kids don’t do homework on the kitchen table with the tablecloth rolled back. They work on laptop computers in their rooms. But they know, because I’ve told them, what it was like to sit there talking to you until Dad got home. How, if I was fast enough, I’d run to my room before he saw me and took a swing.

It’s not your fault, though. I get that you couldn’t figure out how to stop him, that you were protecting yourself too. I’m only a little mad at you for putting your own safety ahead of mine. I’d have put your safety first too, you know. If only you’d asked. You didn’t intend it but you taught me about my own strength. His hands hurt me so much less than they would have hurt you. I’m mostly at peace with it – well, with some of it anyway – and I hope you are too. 

You were never able to forgive yourself for any of your humanity – your flaws, your choices, your life. I hope you have found peace, wherever you are. One time, shortly before you died, my son held your finger and you said to him, “Remember me.” 

It was a lot to ask of him – barely 1 year old when you died. It was a lot to ask of me, too, really. Sometimes I feel like I was just an adult-in-training when you died; but I have kept you alive, in my own way, through my own memories. Perhaps that is enough.

Love you forever, Mom. Happy Mother’s Day.

Back row: My grandparents-C. Park and Marion Graves
Front row: Charles Park Graves, Jr, Mary Ann Graves Ainsworth (my mom), Patricia Graves Thorr, William Graves
To My Mother